一道GMAT逻辑真题!
Oftenpatientswithanklefracturesthatarestable,andthusdonotrequiresurgery,aregivenfollow-upx-raybecausetheirorthopedistsareconcernedaboutpossiblyhavingmisjudgedthestabilityofthefracture.Whennumberoffollow-upx-rayswerereviewed,however,allthefracturesthathadinitiallybeenjudgedstablewerefoundtohavehealedcorrectly.Therefore,itisawasteofmoneytoorderfollow-upx-raysofanklefractureinitiallyjudgedstable.
Whichofthefollowing,iftrue,moststrengthenstheargument?
A)Doctorswhoaregeneralpractitionersratherthanorthopedistsarelesslikelythanorthopediststojudgethestabilityofananklefracturecorrectly.
B)Manyankleinjuriesforwhichaninitialx-rayisorderedarerevealedbythex-raynottoinvolveanyfractureoftheankle.
C)X-raysofpatientsofmanydifferentorthopedistsworkinginseveralhospitalswerereviewed.
D)Thehealingofanklefracturesthathavebeensurgicallyrepairedisalwayscheckedbymeansofafollow-upx-ray.
E)Orthopedistsroutinelyorderfollow-upx-raysforfracturesofboneotherthananklebones
我觉得一楼这个理解有点不对，原文说的不是这个x-ray要不要被review,而是follow-upx-ray是做还是不做的问题。你的解释我觉得是对的！但是B并不是削弱，我觉得应该算notmentioned