字典翻译 问答 其它 请教一道GMAT逻辑题,真心琢磨不明白呀。.....Frobisher,asixteenth-centuryEnglishexplorer,hadsoilsamplesfromCanada'sKodlunarnIslandexaminedforgoldcontent.Becausehighgoldcontentwasreported,ElizabethIfundedtwomining
问题标题:
请教一道GMAT逻辑题,真心琢磨不明白呀。.....Frobisher,asixteenth-centuryEnglishexplorer,hadsoilsamplesfromCanada'sKodlunarnIslandexaminedforgoldcontent.Becausehighgoldcontentwasreported,ElizabethIfundedtwomining
问题描述:

请教一道GMAT逻辑题,真心琢磨不明白呀。.....

Frobisher,a

sixteenth-centuryEnglishexplorer,hadsoilsamplesfromCanada'sKodlunarn

Islandexaminedforgoldcontent.Becausehighgoldcontentwasreported,

ElizabethIfundedtwominingexpeditions.Neitherexpeditionfoundanygold

there.Modernanalysisoftheisland'ssoilindicatesaverylowgoldcontent.Thus

themethodsusedtodeterminethegoldcontentofFrobisher‘ssamplesmusthave

beeninaccurate.

Whichofthe

followingisanassumptiononwhichtheargumentdepends?

A.ThegoldcontentofthesoilonKodlunarnIslandismuch

lowertodaythanitwasinthesixteenthcentury.

B.ThetwominingexpeditionsfundedbyIdidnotminethe

samepartofKodlunarnIsland.

C.Themethodsusedtoassessgoldcontentofthesoil

samplesprovidedbyFrobisherweredifferentfromthosegenerallyusedinthe

sixteenthcentury.

D.Frobisherdidnothavesoilsamplesfromanyother

Canadianislandexaminedforgoldcontent.

E.Goldwasnotaddedtothesamplescollected

byFrobisherbeforethesampleswereexamined.

这道以答案是E,那为什么B不对呢?而且为什么选E,觉得E有点不合理

.

盛跃宾回答:
  问题是,文中的论点,依据于下面哪一个假设?   E没有什么不合理的。   要想文章里的论点成立,那就一定要假设没有人在样品里加进金子。这个假设是一定要有的。   而选项B,是一种可能的解释,但是不是文中论点成立的前提。
点击显示
其它推荐
热门其它推荐
  • 其它